Base code

docs/ALwrity Researcher/PHASE2_IMPLEMENTATION_SUMMARY.md

@@ -0,0 +1,195 @@
+# Phase 2 Implementation Summary: Writing Patterns & Style Intelligence
+
+## Date: 2025-12-31
+
+---
+
+## ✅ **Phase 2 Implementation Complete**
+
+### **What Was Implemented:**
+
+#### **1. Style Patterns → Research Angles** ✅
+
+**Enhancement**: Generate research angles from actual writing patterns
+
+**Changes Made**:
+- Added `_extract_writing_patterns()` method to extract patterns from `style_patterns`
+- Extracts from multiple sources:
+  - `patterns`, `common_patterns`, `writing_patterns`
+  - `content_structure.patterns`
+  - `analysis.identified_patterns`
+- Updated prompt to use extracted patterns for research angles:
+  - "comparison" → "Compare {topic} solutions and alternatives"
+  - "how-to" / "tutorial" → "Step-by-step guide to {topic} implementation"
+  - "case-study" → "Real-world {topic} case studies and success stories"
+  - "trend-analysis" → "Latest {topic} trends and future predictions"
+  - "best-practices" → "{topic} best practices and industry standards"
+  - "review" / "evaluation" → "{topic} review and evaluation criteria"
+  - "problem-solving" → "{topic} problem-solving strategies and solutions"
+
+**Impact**: Research angles now match user's actual writing patterns and content structure
+
+---
+
+#### **2. Vocabulary Level → Keyword Expansion Sophistication** ✅
+
+**Enhancement**: Create keyword expansion patterns matching user's vocabulary level
+
+**Changes Made**:
+- Extract `vocabulary_level` from `content_characteristics`
+- Added vocabulary-based expansion logic:
+  - **Advanced**: Technical, sophisticated terminology
+    - Example: "AI" → ["machine learning algorithms", "neural network architectures", "deep learning frameworks"]
+  - **Medium**: Balanced, professional terminology
+    - Example: "AI" → ["artificial intelligence", "automated systems", "smart technology"]
+  - **Simple**: Accessible, beginner-friendly terminology
+    - Example: "AI" → ["smart technology", "automated tools", "helpful software"]
+- Updated prompt to generate expansions at appropriate complexity level
+
+**Impact**: Keyword expansions now match user's writing sophistication and audience level
+
+---
+
+#### **3. Style Guidelines → Query Enhancement Rules** ✅
+
+**Enhancement**: Create query enhancement rules from style guidelines
+
+**Changes Made**:
+- Added `_extract_style_guidelines()` method to extract guidelines from `style_guidelines`
+- Extracts from multiple sources:
+  - `guidelines`, `recommendations`, `best_practices`
+  - `tone_recommendations`, `structure_guidelines`
+  - `vocabulary_suggestions`, `engagement_tips`
+  - `audience_considerations`, `seo_optimization`, `conversion_optimization`
+- Updated prompt to create enhancement rules from guidelines:
+  - "Use specific examples" → "Research: {query} with specific examples and case studies"
+  - "Include data points" / "statistics" → "Research: {query} including statistics, metrics, and data analysis"
+  - "Reference industry standards" → "Research: {query} with industry benchmarks and best practices"
+  - "Cite authoritative sources" → "Research: {query} from authoritative sources and expert opinions"
+  - "Provide actionable insights" → "Research: {query} with actionable strategies and implementation steps"
+  - "Compare alternatives" → "Research: Compare {query} alternatives and evaluate options"
+
+**Impact**: Query enhancement rules now align with user's writing style and content guidelines
+
+---
+
+## 📋 **Code Changes**
+
+### **File Modified**: `backend/services/research/research_persona_prompt_builder.py`
+
+**Added**:
+1. Extraction of `style_patterns`, `content_characteristics`, `style_guidelines` from website analysis
+2. `_extract_writing_patterns()` method (extracts up to 10 patterns)
+3. `_extract_style_guidelines()` method (extracts up to 15 guidelines)
+4. Vocabulary level extraction and usage
+5. Enhanced prompt instructions for:
+   - Pattern-based research angles
+   - Vocabulary-sophisticated keyword expansion
+   - Guideline-based query enhancement rules
+
+**Prompt Enhancements**:
+- Added "PHASE 2: WRITING PATTERNS & STYLE INTELLIGENCE" section
+- Enhanced "KEYWORD INTELLIGENCE" section with vocabulary-based expansion
+- Enhanced "RESEARCH ANGLES" section with pattern-based generation
+- Enhanced "QUERY ENHANCEMENT" section with guideline-based rules
+
+---
+
+## 🎯 **Expected Benefits**
+
+1. **Pattern-Aligned Research Angles**: Research angles match user's actual writing patterns
+2. **Vocabulary-Appropriate Expansions**: Keyword expansions match user's sophistication level
+3. **Guideline-Based Query Enhancement**: Query rules follow user's style guidelines
+4. **Better Content Alignment**: Research persona reflects user's writing style and preferences
+
+---
+
+## 🔍 **Pattern Extraction Logic**
+
+### **Writing Patterns Extracted From**:
+- `style_patterns.patterns`
+- `style_patterns.common_patterns`
+- `style_patterns.writing_patterns`
+- `style_patterns.content_structure.patterns`
+- `style_patterns.analysis.identified_patterns`
+
+### **Pattern Normalization**:
+- Converted to lowercase
+- Replaced underscores and spaces with hyphens
+- Removed duplicates
+- Limited to 10 most relevant patterns
+
+---
+
+## 📚 **Guideline Extraction Logic**
+
+### **Style Guidelines Extracted From**:
+- `style_guidelines.guidelines`
+- `style_guidelines.recommendations`
+- `style_guidelines.best_practices`
+- `style_guidelines.tone_recommendations`
+- `style_guidelines.structure_guidelines`
+- `style_guidelines.vocabulary_suggestions`
+- `style_guidelines.engagement_tips`
+- `style_guidelines.audience_considerations`
+- `style_guidelines.seo_optimization`
+- `style_guidelines.conversion_optimization`
+
+### **Guideline Normalization**:
+- Removed duplicates (case-insensitive)
+- Filtered out very short guidelines (< 5 characters)
+- Limited to 15 most relevant guidelines
+
+---
+
+## 🧪 **Testing Recommendations**
+
+1. **Test Pattern Extraction**:
+   - User with "comparison" pattern → Should see "Compare {topic} solutions" angle
+   - User with "how-to" pattern → Should see "Step-by-step guide" angle
+   - User with "case-study" pattern → Should see "Real-world case studies" angle
+
+2. **Test Vocabulary Mapping**:
+   - Advanced vocabulary → Should get sophisticated keyword expansions
+   - Simple vocabulary → Should get accessible keyword expansions
+   - Medium vocabulary → Should get balanced keyword expansions
+
+3. **Test Guideline Extraction**:
+   - User with "Use specific examples" guideline → Should see enhancement rule for examples
+   - User with "Include data points" guideline → Should see enhancement rule for statistics
+   - User with "Reference industry standards" guideline → Should see enhancement rule for benchmarks
+
+---
+
+## 📝 **Next Steps (Phase 3)**
+
+### **Phase 3: High Impact, High Effort**
+- Full crawl_result analysis → Topic extraction, theme identification
+- Complete writing style mapping → All research preferences
+- Content strategy intelligence → Comprehensive preset generation
+
+---
+
+## ✅ **Implementation Status**
+
+- ✅ Style patterns extraction and research angle generation
+- ✅ Vocabulary level extraction and sophisticated keyword expansion
+- ✅ Style guidelines extraction and query enhancement rules
+- ✅ Enhanced prompt instructions for all Phase 2 features
+- ✅ Helper methods for pattern and guideline extraction
+
+**Status**: Phase 2 Complete - Ready for Testing
+
+---
+
+## 🔄 **Combined Phase 1 + Phase 2 Benefits**
+
+With both phases implemented, the research persona now:
+1. ✅ Generates presets based on actual content types
+2. ✅ Maps research depth to writing complexity
+3. ✅ Uses extracted keywords from website content
+4. ✅ Creates research angles from writing patterns
+5. ✅ Generates vocabulary-appropriate keyword expansions
+6. ✅ Creates query enhancement rules from style guidelines
+
+**Result**: Highly personalized research persona that reflects user's actual content strategy, writing style, and preferences.