kunthawat/moreminimore-marketing

Fork 0

Files

Kunthawat Greethong c35fa52117 Base code

2026-01-08 22:39:53 +07:00

28 KiB

Raw Blame History

Phase 1 Implementation Review & Gap Analysis

Date: 2025-01-29
Status: ✅ Phase 1 Complete - Ready for End-User Testing

📊 Gap Status Summary

Gap	Status	Implementation Details
1. Persona-Aware Defaults Integration	✅ COMPLETE	Frontend fetches and applies defaults on wizard load
2. Research Persona Integration	✅ COMPLETE	Backend enriches context with persona data
3. Provider Auto-Selection (Exa First)	✅ COMPLETE	Exa → Tavily → Google for all modes
4. Visual Status Indicators	✅ COMPLETE	Provider chips show actual availability
5. Domain Suggestions Auto-Population	✅ VERIFIED	Industry change triggers domain suggestions
6. AI Query Enhancement	❌ NOT STARTED	Phase 2 feature
7. Smart Preset Generation	❌ NOT STARTED	Phase 2 feature (depends on research persona)
8. Date Range & Source Type Filtering	❌ NOT STARTED	Phase 2 feature

Completion Rate: 5/8 gaps addressed (62.5%)

✅ Implemented Features

1. Persona-Aware Defaults Integration ✅

What Was Implemented:

getResearchConfig() now fetches both provider availability AND persona defaults in parallel
ResearchInput.tsx applies persona defaults on component mount:
- Industry auto-fills if currently "General"
- Target audience auto-fills if currently "General"
- Exa domains auto-populate if Exa is available and domains not already set
- Exa category auto-applies if not already set

Files Modified:

frontend/src/api/researchConfig.ts - Fetches persona defaults
frontend/src/components/Research/steps/ResearchInput.tsx - Applies defaults (lines 85-114)

How It Works:

Wizard loads → getResearchConfig() called
API fetches /api/research/persona-defaults in parallel with provider status
If fields are "General" (default), persona defaults are applied
User can still override any auto-filled values

Testing Notes:

✅ Works for new users (fields start as "General")
⚠️ May not apply if localStorage has saved state with non-General values (intentional - respects user choices)
✅ Graceful fallback if persona API fails

2. Research Persona Integration ✅

What Was Implemented:

ResearchEngine now fetches and uses research persona during research execution
Persona data enriches the research context:
- Industry and target audience (if not set)
- Suggested Exa domains (if not set)
- Suggested Exa category (if not set)
Uses cached persona (7-day TTL) - no expensive LLM calls during research

Files Modified:

backend/services/research/core/research_engine.py:
- Added _get_research_persona() method (lines 88-114)
- Added _enrich_context_with_persona() method (lines 116-152)
- Integrated into research() method (lines 171-177)

How It Works:

User executes research → ResearchEngine.research() called
Engine fetches cached research persona for user (if available)
Persona data enriches the ResearchContext:
- Only applies if fields are not already set
- User-provided values always take precedence
Enriched context passed to ParameterOptimizer
Optimizer uses persona data for better parameter selection

Testing Notes:

✅ Only loads cached persona (fast, no LLM calls)
✅ Graceful fallback if persona not available
✅ User overrides are respected
⚠️ Requires user to have completed onboarding and have research persona generated

3. Provider Auto-Selection (Exa First) ✅

What Was Implemented:

Frontend: Auto-selects Exa → Tavily → Google for ALL modes (including basic)
Backend: ParameterOptimizer always prefers Exa → Tavily → Google
Removed mode-based provider selection logic

Files Modified:

frontend/src/components/Research/steps/ResearchInput.tsx (lines 154-191)
backend/services/research/core/parameter_optimizer.py (lines 176-224)

Priority Order:

Exa (Primary) - Neural semantic search, best for all content types
Tavily (Secondary) - AI-powered search, good for real-time/news
Google (Fallback) - Gemini grounding, used when others unavailable

Testing Notes:

✅ Exa selected when available (regardless of mode)
✅ Falls back to Tavily if Exa unavailable
✅ Falls back to Google if both unavailable
✅ User can still manually override provider

4. Visual Status Indicators ✅

What Was Implemented:

ProviderChips component shows actual provider availability
Status dots: Green = configured, Red = not configured
Reordered to show priority: Exa → Tavily → Google
Updated tooltips to indicate provider roles

Files Modified:

frontend/src/components/Research/steps/components/ProviderChips.tsx

Visual Changes:

Exa shown first (primary provider)
Tavily shown second (secondary provider)
Google shown third (fallback provider)
Status dots reflect actual API key configuration

Testing Notes:

✅ Status indicators reflect real API key status
✅ Tooltips explain provider roles
✅ No longer tied to "advanced mode" toggle

5. Domain Suggestions Auto-Population ✅

What Was Implemented:

Industry change triggers domain suggestions (already existed)
Persona defaults also provide domain suggestions
Works for both Exa and Tavily providers

Files Modified:

frontend/src/components/Research/steps/ResearchInput.tsx (lines 193-225)
Uses existing getIndustryDomainSuggestions() utility

How It Works:

User selects industry → useEffect triggers
getIndustryDomainSuggestions(industry) called
Domains auto-populate in Exa config if Exa available
Persona defaults also provide domains on initial load

Testing Notes:

✅ Industry change triggers domain suggestions
✅ Persona defaults provide domains on load
✅ Works for both Exa and Tavily
⚠️ Domains only auto-populate for Exa (Tavily domains need manual transfer)

❌ Remaining Gaps (Phase 2)

6. AI Query Enhancement ❌

Status: Not Started
Priority: High
Dependencies: Research persona (✅ now available)

What's Needed:

Backend service to enhance vague user queries
Endpoint: /api/research/enhance-query
Frontend "Enhance Query" button
Uses research persona's query_enhancement_rules

Implementation Plan:

Create backend/services/research/core/query_enhancer.py
Add /api/research/enhance-query endpoint
Add UI button in ResearchInput.tsx
Integrate with research persona rules

7. Smart Preset Generation ❌

Status: Not Started
Priority: Medium
Dependencies: Research persona (✅ now available)

What's Needed:

Generate presets from research persona
Use persona's recommended_presets field
Display in frontend wizard
Learn from successful research patterns

Implementation Plan:

Use research persona's recommended_presets field
Display presets in ResearchInput.tsx
Add preset generation service (future)
Track successful research patterns (future)

8. Date Range & Source Type Filtering ❌

Status: Not Started
Priority: Medium

What's Needed:

Add date range controls to frontend
Add source type checkboxes
Pass to Research Engine API
Integrate with providers (Tavily supports time_range)

Implementation Plan:

Add date_range and source_types to ResearchContext
Add UI controls (collapsible section or advanced mode)
Update ResearchEngine to pass to providers
Test with Tavily time_range parameter

🧪 End-User Testing Checklist

Test Scenario 1: New User (No Onboarding)

Open Research Wizard
Verify fields start as "General"
Verify provider auto-selects to Exa (if available)
Verify status indicators show correct provider availability
Enter keywords and execute research
Verify research completes successfully

Test Scenario 2: User with Onboarding (Persona Available)

Open Research Wizard
Verify industry auto-fills from persona defaults
Verify target audience auto-fills from persona defaults
Verify Exa domains auto-populate (if Exa available)
Verify Exa category auto-applies
Execute research
Verify backend logs show persona enrichment
Verify research uses persona-suggested domains/category

Test Scenario 3: Provider Availability

Test with Exa available → Should select Exa
Test with only Tavily available → Should select Tavily
Test with only Google available → Should select Google
Verify status chips show correct colors (green/red)
Verify tooltips explain provider roles

Test Scenario 4: Provider Fallback

Configure only Exa → Execute research → Verify Exa used
Disable Exa, enable Tavily → Execute research → Verify Tavily used
Disable both, enable Google → Execute research → Verify Google used

Test Scenario 5: User Overrides

Auto-fill persona defaults
Manually change industry → Verify override works
Manually change provider → Verify override works
Execute research → Verify user values are respected

Test Scenario 6: Domain Suggestions

Select "Healthcare" industry → Verify domains auto-populate
Select "Technology" industry → Verify domains change
Verify domains appear in Exa options
Execute research → Verify domains are used in search

📋 Next Implementation Items (Phase 2)

Priority 1: High-Value Features

1. AI Query Enhancement (High Priority)

Impact: Transforms vague inputs into actionable queries
Effort: Medium (2-3 days)
Dependencies: ✅ Research persona available
Files to Create/Modify:
- backend/services/research/core/query_enhancer.py (NEW)
- backend/api/research/router.py (add endpoint)
- frontend/src/components/Research/steps/ResearchInput.tsx (add button)

2. Research Persona Presets Display (Medium Priority)

Impact: Shows personalized presets from research persona
Effort: Low (1 day)
Dependencies: ✅ Research persona available
Files to Modify:
- frontend/src/components/Research/steps/ResearchInput.tsx (display presets)
- Use research_persona.recommended_presets field

Priority 2: Enhanced Filtering

3. Date Range & Source Type Filtering (Medium Priority)

Impact: Better control over research scope
Effort: Medium (2 days)
Dependencies: None
Files to Modify:
- backend/services/research/core/research_context.py (add fields)
- backend/services/research/core/research_engine.py (pass to providers)
- frontend/src/components/Research/steps/ResearchInput.tsx (add UI)

Priority 3: Advanced Features

4. Smart Preset Generation (Low Priority)

Impact: AI-generated presets based on research history
Effort: High (3-4 days)
Dependencies: Research history tracking
Files to Create/Modify:
- backend/services/research/core/preset_generator.py (NEW)
- Research history tracking service (NEW)

🔍 Known Issues & Limitations

1. Persona Defaults Timing

Issue: Persona defaults only apply if fields are "General"
Impact: If localStorage has saved state, defaults may not apply
Workaround: Clear localStorage or manually reset to "General"
Future Fix: Add "Reset to Persona Defaults" button

2. Domain Suggestions Provider-Specific

Issue: Domain suggestions only auto-populate for Exa
Impact: Tavily domains need manual entry
Future Fix: Auto-populate for both providers

3. Research Persona Cache

Issue: Persona only loaded if cached (7-day TTL)
Impact: New users or expired cache won't get persona benefits
Workaround: Persona generation happens during onboarding or scheduled task
Future Fix: Auto-generate on-demand if cache expired

4. Query Enhancement Not Available

Issue: No way to enhance vague queries
Impact: Users must manually refine queries
Future Fix: Implement AI query enhancement (Phase 2)

📈 Success Metrics

Phase 1 Goals (Current)

✅ Persona defaults auto-apply for onboarded users
✅ Research persona enriches backend research
✅ Exa preferred for all research modes
✅ Provider status clearly visible

Phase 2 Goals (Next)

⏳ AI query enhancement reduces query refinement time
⏳ Smart presets increase research efficiency
⏳ Date range filtering improves result relevance

🎯 Recommendations for Testing

Test with Real User Accounts:
- New user (no onboarding)
- User with completed onboarding
- User with research persona generated
Test Provider Scenarios:
- All providers available
- Only Exa available
- Only Tavily available
- Only Google available
Test Persona Integration:
- Verify persona defaults apply on wizard load
- Verify backend persona enrichment works
- Check backend logs for persona application
Test Edge Cases:
- localStorage with saved state
- Network errors during config fetch
- Missing research persona
- Provider API failures

📝 Summary

Phase 1 Implementation: ✅ COMPLETE

Key Achievements:

Persona-aware defaults integrated (frontend + backend)
Research persona enriches research context
Exa-first provider selection for all modes
Visual status indicators working correctly
Domain suggestions auto-populate

Ready for Testing: ✅ Yes

Next Steps:

End-user testing (current focus)
Phase 2: AI Query Enhancement
Phase 2: Research Persona Presets Display
Phase 2: Date Range & Source Type Filtering

🚀 Phase 2 Implementation Plan (User-Clarified Requirements)

Understanding the Flow

┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                        USER JOURNEY                                  │
├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│  1. User signs up → MUST complete onboarding (mandatory)            │
│     └── Creates: Core Persona, Blog Persona, (opt) Social Personas  │
│                                                                      │
│  2. User accesses Dashboard/Tools (only after onboarding)           │
│                                                                      │
│  3. User visits Researcher (first time)                             │
│     └── Research Persona does NOT exist yet                         │
│     └── System GENERATES Research Persona from Core Persona         │
│     └── Stores in onboarding database                               │
│                                                                      │
│  4. User visits Researcher (subsequent times)                       │
│     └── Research Persona loaded from cache/database                 │
│     └── NO fallback to "General" - always use persona               │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Key User Requirements

Onboarding is mandatory - Users cannot access tools without completing onboarding
Core persona always exists - After onboarding, core persona + blog persona are guaranteed
Research persona generated on first use - NOT during onboarding
Never fallback to "General" - Always use persona data for hyper-personalization
Pre-fill Exa/Tavily options - Make research easier for non-technical users
AI analysis personalized - Use persona to customize research result presentation

Phase 2 Changes Required

1. Backend - Generate Research Persona on First Visit

File: backend/services/research/core/research_engine.py

Current Code (Phase 1):

persona = persona_service.get_cached_only(user_id)  # Never generates

Phase 2 Change:

persona = persona_service.get_or_generate(user_id)  # Generates if missing

Impact:

First-time users get research persona generated automatically
Subsequent users get cached persona (7-day TTL)
LLM API call cost on first research execution

2. Backend - `/api/research/persona-defaults` Enhancement

File: backend/api/research_config.py

Current Behavior:

Uses core persona from onboarding
Falls back to "General" if not found

Phase 2 Change:

Check if research persona exists
If yes → Use research persona fields
If no → Use core persona fields (never "General")
Optionally trigger research persona generation in background

Why: Research persona has better defaults (suggested_exa_domains, suggested_exa_category, research_angles) than core persona.

3. Frontend - Ensure Persona Always Loaded

File: frontend/src/components/Research/steps/ResearchInput.tsx

Current Behavior:

Applies persona defaults if fields are "General"
Falls back to "General" if persona API fails

Phase 2 Change:

Remove fallback to "General"
Show loading state until persona is loaded
If persona fails, show error with retry option
Never proceed with "General" values

4. Frontend - First Visit Detection

File: frontend/src/components/Research/ResearchWizard.tsx or useResearchWizard.ts

Phase 2 Addition:

Check if research persona exists on mount
If not → Show "Generating your personalized research settings..." loading state
Call /api/research/research-persona to trigger generation
Once complete → Load persona defaults into wizard

5. Remove All "General" Fallbacks

Files to Update:

ResearchInput.tsx - Remove "General" default values
useResearchWizard.ts - Remove "General" from defaultState
researchConfig.ts - Remove empty fallback for PersonaDefaults
research_engine.py - Remove context creation without personalization

Why: User explicitly stated "no fallback to General" - always use persona data.

Implementation Order

Step 1: Backend - Enable Research Persona Generation on First Use

File: backend/services/research/core/research_engine.py
Change: get_cached_only() → get_or_generate()
Risk: LLM API cost on first research
Mitigation: Rate limiting already in place

Step 2: Backend - Enhance Persona Defaults Endpoint

File: backend/api/research_config.py
Change: Use research persona fields if available
Why: Research persona has richer defaults

Step 3: Frontend - First Visit Research Persona Generation Flow

Files: ResearchWizard.tsx, useResearchWizard.ts
Change: Add generation flow for first-time users
UX: Show friendly loading state during generation

Step 4: Remove "General" Fallbacks

Files: Multiple frontend and backend files
Change: Replace "General" with persona-derived values
Why: Hyper-personalization requirement

Step 5: Pre-fill Advanced Exa/Tavily Options

Files: ResearchInput.tsx, ExaOptions.tsx, TavilyOptions.tsx
Change: Auto-populate from research persona
Why: Simplify UI for non-technical users

Testing Checklist for Phase 2

Test Scenario 1: First-Time Researcher User

User completes onboarding (has core persona, blog persona)
User visits Researcher for first time
Shows "Generating personalized research settings..." loading
Research persona is generated (check backend logs)
Wizard fields auto-populate with persona data (NOT "General")
Execute research → verify persona enrichment in backend

Test Scenario 2: Returning Researcher User

User with existing research persona visits Researcher
Persona loaded from cache (no generation)
Wizard fields auto-populate correctly
Execute research → verify cached persona used

Test Scenario 3: Expired Cache

User with expired research persona (>7 days) visits Researcher
Persona is regenerated (check backend logs)
New persona used for research

Test Scenario 4: No "General" Values

Verify industry is never "General"
Verify target audience is never "General"
Verify Exa domains/category are always populated
Verify Tavily options are pre-filled

API Flow Diagram

┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                    PHASE 2 API FLOW                                  │
├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│                                                                      │
│  User Opens Researcher                                               │
│         │                                                            │
│         ▼                                                            │
│  ┌─────────────────────────────────────┐                            │
│  │ GET /api/research/persona-defaults  │                            │
│  │  + GET /api/research/providers/status                            │
│  └─────────────────────────────────────┘                            │
│         │                                                            │
│         ▼                                                            │
│  ┌─────────────────────────────────────┐                            │
│  │ Backend checks research persona     │                            │
│  │ exists in cache/database?           │                            │
│  └─────────────────────────────────────┘                            │
│         │                                                            │
│    ┌────┴────┐                                                       │
│   YES        NO                                                      │
│    │          │                                                      │
│    ▼          ▼                                                      │
│ ┌──────┐  ┌───────────────────────────┐                             │
│ │Return│  │ Generate research persona │                             │
│ │cached│  │ from core persona (LLM)   │                             │
│ │data  │  │ Save to database          │                             │
│ └──────┘  │ Return generated data     │                             │
│    │      └───────────────────────────┘                             │
│    │          │                                                      │
│    └────┬─────┘                                                      │
│         ▼                                                            │
│  ┌─────────────────────────────────────┐                            │
│  │ Frontend receives persona defaults  │                            │
│  │ (industry, audience, domains, etc.) │                            │
│  └─────────────────────────────────────┘                            │
│         │                                                            │
│         ▼                                                            │
│  ┌─────────────────────────────────────┐                            │
│  │ Auto-populate wizard fields         │                            │
│  │ (NO "General" values)               │                            │
│  └─────────────────────────────────────┘                            │
│         │                                                            │
│         ▼                                                            │
│  User Executes Research                                              │
│         │                                                            │
│         ▼                                                            │
│  ┌─────────────────────────────────────┐                            │
│  │ POST /api/research/start            │                            │
│  │ (ResearchEngine.research())         │                            │
│  └─────────────────────────────────────┘                            │
│         │                                                            │
│         ▼                                                            │
│  ┌─────────────────────────────────────┐                            │
│  │ Backend enriches context with       │                            │
│  │ research persona (cached)           │                            │
│  │ → AI optimizes Exa/Tavily params    │                            │
│  │ → Executes research                 │                            │
│  │ → AI analyzes results (personalized)│                            │
│  └─────────────────────────────────────┘                            │
│         │                                                            │
│         ▼                                                            │
│  ┌─────────────────────────────────────┐                            │
│  │ Return personalized research results│                            │
│  └─────────────────────────────────────┘                            │
│                                                                      │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Benefits of Phase 2

Zero Configuration for Users: Research works out-of-box with personalized settings
Hyper-Personalization: Every research is tailored to user's industry and audience
No Technical Complexity: Exa/Tavily options pre-filled, hidden from users
Consistent Experience: No "General" fallbacks - always meaningful defaults
AI-Optimized Results: Research output digestible and relevant to user's needs

Document Version: 1.1
Last Updated: 2025-01-29
Phase 2 Status: Ready for Implementation

28 KiB Raw Blame History

Phase 1 Implementation Review & Gap Analysis

📊 Gap Status Summary

✅ Implemented Features

1. Persona-Aware Defaults Integration ✅

2. Research Persona Integration ✅

3. Provider Auto-Selection (Exa First) ✅

4. Visual Status Indicators ✅

5. Domain Suggestions Auto-Population ✅

❌ Remaining Gaps (Phase 2)

6. AI Query Enhancement ❌

7. Smart Preset Generation ❌

8. Date Range & Source Type Filtering ❌

🧪 End-User Testing Checklist

Test Scenario 1: New User (No Onboarding)

Test Scenario 2: User with Onboarding (Persona Available)

Test Scenario 3: Provider Availability

Test Scenario 4: Provider Fallback

Test Scenario 5: User Overrides

Test Scenario 6: Domain Suggestions

📋 Next Implementation Items (Phase 2)

Priority 1: High-Value Features

Priority 2: Enhanced Filtering

Priority 3: Advanced Features

🔍 Known Issues & Limitations

1. Persona Defaults Timing

2. Domain Suggestions Provider-Specific

3. Research Persona Cache

4. Query Enhancement Not Available

📈 Success Metrics

Phase 1 Goals (Current)

Phase 2 Goals (Next)

🎯 Recommendations for Testing

📝 Summary

🚀 Phase 2 Implementation Plan (User-Clarified Requirements)

Understanding the Flow

Key User Requirements

Phase 2 Changes Required

1. Backend - Generate Research Persona on First Visit

2. Backend - /api/research/persona-defaults Enhancement

3. Frontend - Ensure Persona Always Loaded

4. Frontend - First Visit Detection

5. Remove All "General" Fallbacks

Implementation Order

Step 1: Backend - Enable Research Persona Generation on First Use

Step 2: Backend - Enhance Persona Defaults Endpoint

Step 3: Frontend - First Visit Research Persona Generation Flow

Step 4: Remove "General" Fallbacks

Step 5: Pre-fill Advanced Exa/Tavily Options

Testing Checklist for Phase 2

Test Scenario 1: First-Time Researcher User

Test Scenario 2: Returning Researcher User

Test Scenario 3: Expired Cache

Test Scenario 4: No "General" Values

API Flow Diagram

Benefits of Phase 2

28 KiB

Raw Blame History

2. Backend - `/api/research/persona-defaults` Enhancement